the most sustainable prawns to buy this christmas

Posted on December 12th, 2013

I’m not sure if you’re aware but prawns – or shrimp – are an ecological and ethical disaster waiting for a barbie to be thrown atop.

Image via One Bite More

Image via One Bite More

I wasn’t…until recently. My uncle Pete was a trawler. We ate them every Christmas. And in fried rice when Mum made it for one of my brother’s birthdays most years. But I, like many of us, care more about this kind of thing these days. I care, and I want to act right. So prawns…

As with all my sustainable eating posts, I don’t suggest banning foods. I advise making better/best choices. And using up leftovers and the whole animal/vegetable/mineral. Wastage is the real ethical/eco crime, to my mind. In time for Christmas I decided to research this bottom dweller issue and share what I found, so we you, too, can get real to your shrimp.

Why are prawns a problem?

The bycatch is shocking:  I’ve heard anecdotally that

for every prawn caught, 27 other species are caught in the bycatch and tossed away.

World Wildlife Fund (WWF) best describes this issue here, claiming:

Tropical shrimp trawling (TST) has one of the largest bycatch rates of all fishing techniques and often damages the ocean´s seafloor.”

Bottom trawling is shocking: it destroys coral and has a detrimental affect on the seafloor. Seafloors are vital to the health of coral forests, seagrass beds, kelp forests and deep sea thermal vents.

Many of the prawns we buy are imported. About 70 per cent of the seafood Australians consume is from OS. Which is an issue because many countries don’t fish their prawns sustainably. Tropical shrimp farms in Asia  - where much of our prawns come from – destroy coastal mangroves.

So, what to look for?

As I say, I’m not about banning prawns. It’s about getting smart and mindful. There are tricks.

1. Look for Marine Stewardship Council- certified. Ask your monger if the prawns they’re selling are as such. MSC is the biggest fishery standard (with more than 200,000 fish covered in over 15 countries) and therefore this first port of call is probably your safest bet, wherever you are in the world. MSC-certified prawns are trawled on sandy or muddy ocean floors and cause minimal impact to the habitat and ecosystem. But, somewhat contentiously, not all their recommended prawns are low-bycatch.

The Aquaculture Stewardship Council (ASC) is also setting up, and when farms start to become certified by them you’ll be able to look out for their ecolabel too. (At the moment there’s no farms in Australia yet certified.)

2. Choose Northern Prawn Fishery (NPF) prawns, which include banana, tiger and endeavour. They’re found in the big retailers and mongers as NPF is the largest prawn fishery in Australia. But do note they are one of the fisheries with high bycatch.

3. Choose Australian. Pam from the Australian Marine Conservation Society (AMCS) suggests you go for “amber-listed” Australian-caught prawns. Check out their “red”, “amber”, “green” sustainable seafood guide for all fish.

4. Choose estuary or river prawns, says Nathaniel from Greenpeace. You should choose local estuary or river prawns (school prawns) that aren’t trawled – Clarence River Prawns are a good choice.

5. If you’re going for farmed prawns… choose a farm that uses land-based ponds with closed-loop technology (so there are no pollutants) put out into the water. So says Greenpeace’s Nathaniel. Charlotte from MSC adds that you should opt for Australian or New Zealand farmed seafood as they have excellent management practices in place.

6. In restaurants choose Spencer Gulf King Prawns. They’re another MSC recommendation.

7. Avoid prawns imported from South East Asia. Most are raised in unsustainable farms on reclaimed mangrove forest, are polluted with chemicals and effluent, and fed on many kilos of wild-caught trash fish (that’s the leftovers from destructive bottom trawling).

And where to buy them?

* For a full list of certified suppliers and where to find MSC-certified seafood in Australia go here.

* In Sydney Joto Fresh supply great sustainable prawns. They work to BAP, UNFAO and MSC certification. Check out their CleanFish Australia retail program.

* Elsewhere, MSC also has an app that helps you find good shrimp internationally.

The lovely Charlotte from MSC also shared these ideas with us:

* If you’re in Sydney check out Taronga Zoo The View Café for a delicious sustainable prawn lunch.

* Or for dinner you can’t go past Fish & Co in Annandale. Executive Chef Tom Kime has travelled the world researching sustainable seafood and makes a mean Vietnamese prawn cake.

* In Brisbane, try Swamp Dog. Although not yet certified, this fish and chip store uses a lot of MSC-certified sustainable seafood and their Northern Prawn Fishery popcorn prawns are to die for.

* While in Melbourne, Neil Perry’s Rock Pool has Chain of Custody certification and serves Spencer Gulf King Prawns.

* In Adelaide, visit the Adelaide Showground Farmers Market where fishermen from the community-based Lakes and Coorong fishery sell their certified sustainable seafood.

* In WA, relax with some live music and enjoy certified sustainable and Chain of Custody-certified prawns at Clancy’s Fish Pubs.

Are supermarket prawns OK?

Well, I’m glad you asked. Turns out Aldi is the best supermarket to get your prawns. They have a buying policy for all seafood products – fresh, frozen, canned, wild caught and farmed. The policy is already in place (unlike the other supermarkets) and is very comprehensive, with guidelines covering fish range, traceability, and labelling.

While Coles promises it’s seafood will all be sustainably sourced by 2015, Woolworths’ commitment is to wild-caught fish only. Just so you know.

That said, the supermarkets don’t actually explain what ‘sustainably sourced’ is, so it’s open to the supermarkets to make their own changes without going the full distance. More work needs to be done in this area. The good news is the supermarkets do seem to be responding to consumer pressure. The best pressure comes when we vote with our dollars!

Do you have any extra questions? I’ll get the various experts I consulted to wade in and answer if so. Shoot!

Related Posts with Thumbnails
  • Pingback: Your cut ‘n’ keep Sustainable Seafood Swaps » I Quit Sugar

  • Pingback: Your cut ‘n’ keep Sustainable Seafood Swaps » I Quit Sugar

  • melissa

    I just bought ALDI frozen prawns and says they’re from Malaysia, surely you’re not saying these are good? Thinking of taking them back because I don’t ever buy Asian seafood. So what good Aldi prawns are you talking about they only sell ones from Asia?

    [Reply]

  • Em

    The most sustainable way to buy prawns is to not buy prawns. In your effort to support “sustainability”, it might be a good idea to put the health of the planet before your own personal desires to consume a particular food.

    [Reply]

  • Prawn Farmer Cait

    In regards to Woolworths not committing to sustainable seafood this is not true. By 2017 all farmed tiger prawns sold through Woolworths will be grown using 100% sustainable practices

    [Reply]

  • Prawn Farmer Cait

    If you are unsure about the sustainability of any seafood the Australian Marine Conservation Society had developed a free app called ‘sustainable seafood guide’ – it’s an excellent tool to pull out if you’re in the supermarket or at the fish mongerers

    [Reply]

  • Prawn Farmer Cait

    Hi Petra, I don’t know much about wild-caught prawns in woolworths but I grow farmed prawns for them and the only preservatives we use are salt, kakadu plum extract which is basically just vitamin c and lactic acid which is naturally occurs in muscle tissue. You would be hard pressed buying prawns without preservatives and I would not recommend it, their flesh is very delicate and will break down with natural enzyme activity rapidly. Preservatives maintain the beautiful texture and taste we love in prawns and prevent food poisoning. I understand many other food products contain unnecessary and nasty preservatives but it is necessary for seafood products and you will find there are naturally sourced preservatives in use.

    [Reply]